Malarkey roofing shingles review for Chicago-area homeowners. Vista, Legacy, and Highlander lines. Sustainability, performance, and warranty compared.
Malarkey Roofing Products is the brand most homeowners haven't heard of — but should. Based in Portland, Oregon, Malarkey has been manufacturing shingles since 1956 and has quietly built a reputation among roofing contractors for making some of the most durable, innovative, and environmentally responsible shingles in the industry.
What Sets Malarkey Apart
Rubberized Asphalt (Polymer Modified)
This is Malarkey's biggest differentiator. While most manufacturers use standard oxidized asphalt, Malarkey uses Engineered with Polymer Modified (PM) asphalt — essentially rubberized asphalt that's more flexible and durable. In Illinois, where freeze-thaw cycles cause standard asphalt to become brittle over time, Malarkey's polymer-modified formulation maintains flexibility longer, resisting cracking and granule loss that shortens the life of conventional shingles.
Scotchgard Protector from 3M
Malarkey partners with 3M to incorporate Scotchgard algae resistance directly into the granules. This prevents the dark algae streaks that are common on Illinois roofs, especially on north-facing slopes with limited sun exposure. The Scotchgard technology has a proven track record and is backed by 3M's quality standards.
Sustainability / Recycled Content
Malarkey is the industry leader in sustainable roofing. Their shingles incorporate post-consumer recycled rubber and plastics (upcycled from tires and other waste streams), reducing landfill waste while improving shingle flexibility and performance. For environmentally conscious homeowners, this is a meaningful differentiator.
Malarkey Product Lines
Malarkey Vista AR (Architectural)
The entry-level architectural shingle. Strong wind resistance (110 MPH), Scotchgard protection, polymer-modified asphalt, and a 30-year limited warranty. Comparable to GAF Timberline NS and CertainTeed Landmark standard. A solid choice for homeowners wanting Malarkey quality at an accessible price point.
Malarkey Legacy
The mid-tier premium product. Heavier weight, thicker profile, enhanced polymer modification, and a limited lifetime warranty. The Legacy line offers a more dimensional, high-definition look than Vista and includes NEX polymer-modified asphalt for maximum flexibility and durability. This is Malarkey's most popular product and our top recommendation in the Malarkey lineup.
Malarkey Highlander NEX AR
The premium tier. Maximum weight, thickest profile, highest polymer content, and Malarkey's strongest warranty. Features NEX rubberized asphalt for the ultimate in flexibility, impact resistance, and longevity. For homeowners wanting the absolute best Malarkey offers, the Highlander NEX is the top of the line.
Malarkey vs GAF vs CertainTeed
All three make excellent shingles. Malarkey's edge is in the polymer-modified asphalt technology — no other major manufacturer uses rubberized asphalt at this level. For Illinois homeowners who want maximum freeze-thaw resistance and the longest possible shingle life, Malarkey's formulation has a scientific advantage. GAF's edge is in wind resistance (LayerLock) and market availability. CertainTeed's edge is in their integrated roof system warranty.
Do We Install Malarkey?
Yes. We install Malarkey products across Chicagoland alongside GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed. For homeowners interested in Malarkey's polymer-modified technology or sustainability focus, we can present Malarkey options alongside the other manufacturers during your free consultation. Call (331) 250-3726 to schedule.
Related Articles
CertainTeed Landmark PRO Review
GAF vs CertainTeed vs Malarkey Comparison
What matters as much as the shingle
Shingle brands compete closely, and all the major architectural lines perform well. Roofs fail early for other reasons: flashing that was reused, missing ice barrier at the eaves, too few nails or nails placed too high, and attics that cannot breathe. When you compare estimates, compare the whole system: underlayment, ice and water barrier, starter, ridge cap, flashing and ventilation. A written scope that lists each one tells you more than the brand name on the wrapper.
Hail and wind ratings in plain terms
Impact resistance is rated Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 the toughest. In a hail-prone area such as ours, a Class 4 shingle can be worth the extra cost, and some insurers offer a premium discount for it. Wind warranties depend on the shingle being installed with the right number of nails and the matching starter strip. Ask your contractor to show that on the estimate.
Common questions
Ready to Get Started?
We install all major brands — Andersen, GAF, CertainTeed, Malarkey, ProVia, Kolbe, and more. Free consultation, transparent pricing, no pressure.
Free Consultation →Or call (331) 250-3726