Malarkey Roofing Shingles Review: Why Illinois Contractors Are Switching (2026)

Malarkey Roofing Products is gaining serious traction in the Chicagoland market, and for good reason. Their rubberized SBS-modified asphalt technology offers performance advantages that are particularly relevant for Illinois weather. Here's why more contractors and homeowners are paying attention.

What Makes Malarkey Different: SBS Rubberized Asphalt

Most shingle manufacturers use oxidized asphalt — a process that makes asphalt stiffer and more brittle. Malarkey uses SBS (Styrene-Butadiene-Styrene) polymer-modified asphalt, which stays flexible even in extreme cold. Why does this matter in Illinois? Because when temperatures drop below zero, standard oxidized asphalt shingles become brittle and can crack during installation, from foot traffic, or from impact. SBS-modified shingles stay pliable, which means better cold-weather performance, better impact resistance, and better long-term durability through our brutal freeze-thaw cycles.

Malarkey Product Lines

Vista AR (Architectural Residential)

Malarkey's most popular residential shingle. Vista AR features SBS-modified asphalt, Class 4 impact resistance (highest rating), and Malarkey's Scotchgard Protector by 3M for algae resistance. The 130 mph wind rating and NEX polymer-modified asphalt make it one of the most durable architectural shingles on the market. Available in a range of colors designed for Midwest home styles.

Legacy

Malarkey's premium designer shingle with a distinctive multi-width profile that mimics the look of natural wood shake. Legacy uses the same SBS-modified asphalt as Vista AR but with a thicker, heavier construction and the multi-shadow line that gives roofs an upscale, dimensional appearance. A strong choice for homeowners wanting designer aesthetics with rubberized durability.

Highlander NEX AR

Malarkey's value-tier architectural shingle. Still uses NEX polymer-modified asphalt (better than standard oxidized asphalt) but at a lower price point than Vista. A solid option for homeowners who want better-than-basic performance without the premium price.

Malarkey's Environmental Innovation

Malarkey incorporates smog-reducing granules (3M Smog-Reducing Granules) into their shingles. These photocatalytic granules use sunlight to break down airborne pollutants — specifically nitrogen oxides (NOx) from vehicle emissions. It's a genuine environmental benefit: Malarkey estimates that one roof with their granules has the same smog-reducing effect as planting two trees. For environmentally conscious Chicagoland homeowners, this is a unique differentiator that no other major shingle manufacturer offers.

Malarkey vs. GAF vs. CertainTeed vs. Owens Corning

• Cold-weather flexibility — Malarkey wins. SBS-modified asphalt stays pliable in sub-zero temperatures when oxidized asphalt becomes brittle.
• Impact resistance — Malarkey Vista AR is Class 4 standard. GAF Timberline HDZ requires specifying the IR version. CertainTeed and Owens Corning offer impact-resistant upgrades at additional cost.
• Color selection — GAF and CertainTeed have broader color palettes. Malarkey's selection is growing but still smaller.
• Availability — GAF and CertainTeed are more widely available from distributors. Malarkey is growing its Midwest distribution but may have slightly longer lead times for some colors.
• Environmental impact — Malarkey wins decisively with smog-reducing granules and recycled materials in the base mat.

Should You Choose Malarkey for Your Chicagoland Roof?

If cold-weather performance, impact resistance, and environmental responsibility are priorities, Malarkey Vista AR is worth serious consideration. The SBS-modified asphalt technology is genuinely superior for Illinois freeze-thaw conditions. We install Malarkey, GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed — and we're happy to help you compare options during your free consultation. Learn about our roofing services →